Lodge Chiefs
Allogagan Lodge #83 (Hampden Council)
| 1936-1937 | Clayton Moore | 1950 | Donald George |
| 1938 | John Turner | 1951 | Robert Keyes |
| 1939 | Robert Bush | 1952 | Allan Damon |
| 1940 | William Lynch | 1953 | Ben Wood |
| 1941 | Walter Doyle | 1954-1955 | Edward Salamano |
| 1942 | Augustus Newman | 1956 | Robert Veideman |
| 1943-1944 | Robert Huckins | 1957 | Edward Williams |
| 1945 | Frederick Torrey | 1958-1959 | Roger Norton |
| 1946 | James Hawkins | 1960 | John Nowak |
| 1947-1948 | Norman Wood | 1961 | Thomas Guyton |
| 1949 | Marshall (Ted) Keyes | ||
Apinakwi Pita Lodge #277 (Mt. Tom Council)
| 1944 | George Washington | 1953 | Paul Czajkowski |
| 1945 | George Bradley | 1954 | John Cavagnaro |
| 1946 | Richard Paquette | 1955-1956 | John Sullivan |
| 1947-1948 | Donald Cousineau | 1957 | John Donahue |
| 1949 | Matthew Donachie | 1958 | Russell Mroczek |
| 1950-1951 | Norbert Renaud | 1959 | Alexander Brough |
| 1952 | James Connor | 1960-1961 | Jay Camp |
Allogagan Lodge #83 (Pioneer Valley Council)
| 1962 | William Barber | 1984 | Olen Bielski |
| 1963 | John Eyles | 1985 | James Ransom |
| 1963-1964 | Jeffrey Sargent | 1986 | Michael Sullivan |
| 1965-1966 | David Marble | 1987 | Gary Condon |
| 1967 | Steven Burritt | 1988 | Anthony Pepe |
| 1968 | Paul Boucher | 1989 | Richard Duquette |
| 1969 | Thomas Kuczmarski | 1990 | Jeffrey Dean |
| 1970 | James Hitchcock | 1991 | Brian Patingre |
| 1971 | Jon Reske | 1992 | Craig Vershon |
| 1972-1973 | Mark Piscioneri | 1993 | Todd Chartier |
| 1974 | Craig Plante | 1994-1995 | Severn Goodwin |
| 1974 | Robert Liptak | 1996 | Brian Gerstenberger |
| 1975 | Walter Mitus | 1997 | Mark Stierle |
| 1975 | David Burrage | 1998 | Colin Pekruhn |
| 1975 | Michael Pise | 1999 | Brian Landry |
| 1976 | William Falconer IV | 2000-2002 | Michael Breor |
| 1977 | Mark Rogers | 2003 | Daniel O'Rourke |
| 1978 | Scott Bailey | 2004 | Andrew Ouellet |
| 1979 | Andrew Moore | 2004-2005 | Joseph Micucci |
| 1980-1981 | Richard Robie | 2006 | Samuel C. Everett |
| 1982 | Olen Bielski | 2007 | Lucas Graffum |
| 1983 | David Amo | 2008 | Nicholas Maslon |
| 2008 | Patrick Goldrup | ||
Pe Nain Sew Ne Tami Lodge #507 (Berkshire Council)
Metacomet Lodge #556 (Hampshire-Franklin Council)
Memsochet Lodge #507 (Great Trails Council)
| 1999-2001 | Gregory Fensted | 2004-2005 | Brian Regan |
| 2001-2003 | Joshua Fournier | 2005-2007 | Hunter McCormick |
| 2003-2004 | Hunter McCormick | 2007-2008 | Nathan Morin |
Pocumtuc Lodge (Western Massachusetts Council)
| 2008-2009 | Patrick Goldrup* | 2014-2015 | Eli Harris |
| 2008-2009 | Nathan Morin* | 2015-2016 | Joshua Laprade |
| 2009-2010 | Peter Sauriol | 2016-2018 | Brian Shea |
| 2010-2011 | Nick Axton | 2018-2020 | Kenny White |
| 2011-2013 | Mitchell Heisler | 2020-2020 | Eddie Brannan |
| 2013-2014 | Erik Bernier | 2020- | Nelson Jack Sharpe |
*Co-Chiefs after the merger